idaelmanta's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Naruto Vs Sasuke:Rage]

sprites are nice!

you make wonderful sprites and so far you're the one i find the best in making them. ^^ i'm also a big fan of the Naruto series and I thank you for your tribute to that great anime!

moving on, i think that you may want to improve your camera movements. they could've added more flair in your flash. there were also some strange settings like that weird underground lair which is slightly inappropriate for the fight. i noticed you lacked some sound effects and voice-overs, Naruto kept repeating the same line... which is kind of a distraction. I'm not sure if I'm the only one experiencing this, but I can't see the text. It would've been nicer tif i could see it... I also found the ending a bit strange because I didn't figure out the last part because I couldn't really read the text, you could've improved the ending a bit though. But overall, it's a good flash. Short, but good. Hope this was helpful enough... ^^

[(2006) Trapper!]

clay men are hella fun. C:

This would have to be the most fun claymation I've SEEN! I adore clay! I'm such a big fan of clay!~ I'm just never good at it... :C

Your claymation is superb and the dubbing syncs with the claymen very well. btw, did you do all the dubbing yourself? Anyway, those were some awesome animations you did for the characters! I liked how the claymen seemed so... lifelike. There some scenes that the angles became "out" of the pic and the abrupt change in lighting was kind of a distraction. Might wanna be a teeny bit careful next time.

A hell of an ovation you got here. Keep up the good work. ^^

[Zombie Lobotomy]

a grim encounter indeed.

Not to be impolite but, I've seen plenty of flash with this kind of style and graphics. ^^ Might I suggest that you work on a more definite style of your own because your style resembles too many that I've seen in NG so far. I hope to see something a bit more different on your upcoming projects. You've got really wonderful ideas but somehow they don't show too well in the flash. I really believe you've got something going on so keep it up.

Also, the sound was a bit to "heavy" for the speakers so it doesn't sound very good specially on a louder volume. But it just could've been the speakers here. I'm okay with violence and (zombies should be shot at one kill for them to suffer and die) so I gave that a ten. Well, good luck on your next. ^^

Gi-go responds:

Thats odd to me because I've made my own style over the years by just taking ideas that I like, and very few of them were from this site. My ideas don't show up well in flash? Well of course I wont be able to get the exact picture in my head on the screen but its about what I expected. Well I know my speakers play it well and some other reviewer said it worked well on his too so maybe its just yours. Thanks!

[Final Fantasy A+]

Brilliant. Flawless.

This has all the potential of becoming an RPG if you want it to. A great movie enjoyable for all.

Your Japanese accent's not that bad, you must've worked hard in acting as voice talent in nearly all the characters, excellent job. ^^

[Shoo Fly]

Gets better everytime.

You're a very versatile artist and have got a lot to offer. We'll be waiting for more of your work even if it takes long. ^^